- A recent analysis found that highly engineered consumables are potentially as addictive as tobacco products.
- Scientists found that UPFs are formulated to maximize reward and speed up the absorption of reinforcing components.
- The “addictive” property of these foods suggests they drive uncontrollable eating and interfere with natural hunger cues.
- The researchers recommend that UPFs should be subject to regulations akin to those for cigarettes.
At present, there is no one agreed-upon definition of ultraprocessed foods. Some people classify them as foods that contain components you would not find in a personal cupboard, like stabilizers and additives.
Many professionals rely on the NOVA classification to define ultraprocessed foods. This describes products that contain “combinations of components, mostly of exclusive industrial use, often produced by a set of industrial techniques and methods.”
A recent paper featured in The Millbank Quarterly proposed that ultraprocessed foods could be as addictive as tobacco products.
“It is my view with these findings, as UPFs are intentionally formulated to be extremely attractive to the majority of people,” commented a weight loss specialist who was not involved in the research.
A study from 2023 calculates that more than 73% of the food supply in the US is classified as highly processed.
“Tobacco and UPFs are not just whole foods but highly engineered consumable products engineered deliberately to optimize physical and mental reward and habitual overuse,” explained the review’s research team.
Are UPFs Habit-Forming?
The paper combined data from addiction, public health history, and dietary science in order to highlight textural and compositional qualities that increase the addictive quality of both cigarettes and UPFs.
“Not everyone is ‘addicted’’ to these foods, but for a meaningful minority, they elicit typical habit-forming behaviors: intense desires, loss of control, and persistent consumption despite negative health effects,” commented a heart health nutrition expert.
“These foods are intentionally designed with processed carbohydrates, extra oils, salt, and flavor enhancers to maximize pleasure and repeat consumption, and the industry employs persuasive advertising strategies, especially targeting children,” she added.
The researchers focused on five key areas:
- delivery speed
- hedonic engineering, or creating products to be irresistibly good
- perfecting the amount
- environmental ubiquity
- deceptive reformulation, or “health washing”
It was observed that, similar to tobacco, UPFs are fine-tuned to deliver the right dose of sweetness.
“Processed carbs trigger dopamine production through the vagus nerve, whereas lipids achieve this via intestinal lipid sensing,” the authors noted.
“… UPFs with significant amounts of refined carbohydrates and added fats are among the most potently rewarding foods in the contemporary food supply. Notably this refined carbohydrate-fat mix is almost nonexistent in nature.”
The way these foods rapidly deliver “pleasure-inducing” chemicals to the brain renders them potentially addictive, in a comparable way to tobacco.
The paper noted that while cigarettes are designed to provide nicotine quickly, ultraprocessed foods are formulated to rapidly digest and absorb, as they typically have little to no dietary fiber. This makes it easier for the system to process lipids and carbohydrates more quickly.
The researchers also explain that UPFs provide deliberate flavor bursts that fade quickly and textures that melt in your mouth. This collectively works to trigger more dopamine and prompts individuals to consume additional amounts.
‘Health Washing’ in Cigarettes, Ultraprocessed Foods
Based on the analysis, both the tobacco and processed food industries have long used a tactic called “wellness branding.”
This is where goods are advertised and reformulated to generate an illusion of reduced harm while maintaining the core of their qualities.
This tactic in the cigarette sector became popular in the mid-20th century with the introduction of filters on cigarettes.
They were marketed as safety features that would catch tar and particles before they entered the respiratory system. The truth is, these tips offer little significant protection.
Yet, people typically adjusted by inhaling deeper or increasing consumption, which negated any decrease in harmful intake.
Food manufacturers has adopted a similar approach. It uses packaging claims such as “low fat” or “sugar-free” to market ultraprocessed foods.
Yet, these items often retain the same highly reinforcing ingredient combinations. The problem is that these reformulations offer a superficial impression of wellness while the item’s addictive structure and health risks persist unchanged.
Ought UPFs Be Regulated?
The researchers noted at the conclusion of their paper that nourishment and smoking products are not the same thing.
Nevertheless, they cautioned that certain ultraprocessed foods act like highly optimized products rather than actual food. They proposed that public health policy ought to acknowledge this reality.
“Tobacco offers a cautionary tale, and tobacco control offers a source of potential,” the authors stated.
Because of policies, cigarette use rates in the United States have declined and have “altered public perception of smoking and diminished trust in the industry.”
“It is my opinion increased education about the harmful effects of ultra-processed foods is crucial to reduce public intake and improve population wellness. The approaches employed to reduce tobacco use have been effective and may be a useful blueprint for ultra-processed foods as well,” said one specialist.
“I don’t think UPFs should be regulated exactly like tobacco, but they certainly deserve more robust, tobacco-inspired measures: advertising limits, obvious front-of-package labeling, stricter rules on health claims, and restrictions in schools or medical facilities,” noted another dietitian.
The researchers pointed out to people that minimally processed and whole foods have supported our well-being for millennia.